Our reviews
Reviews from Grubhub
Robbin
Top Reviewer
Last weekend I ordered from Marios for the first time. Whenever I order, because i hate to cook, I order enough food for two nights. It usually works out that way with most places to meet the minimum and I love leftovers. This particular evening, I ordered a Greek salad bread bowl, a side of meatballs (3) and a slice of spinach white pizza. The salad was fabulous, and Im a salad critic :-) I froze the pizza because I was full from the salad and also froze the three huge meatballs. Long story short, I just defrosted them to have tonight and only was able to finish 1.5 because they were so big, but more importantly, they were absolutely delish (Im also a pretty tough meatball critic!). They were as good if not better than any homemade meatballs Ive ever had, so fresh and flavorful and just the right texture. Ill have the other portion tomorrow and the pizza, which looks incredible and is humongous, another night. I dont expect you to also get four meals from one order but do expect you to order Marios ASAP! Its truly delicious, the food came hot and on time and the portions are very generous. Enjoy!
Anthony
Top Reviewer
Very happy with this order, I ordered pizza from here once and it was greasy, but tasty, this time I ordered the Caesar bread bowl and a buffalo roll up. Everything was good and hot, the bread bowl was amazing, I will be ordering again.
Gina
Top Reviewer
I've ordered from Mario's a a few times now. (My son and daughter in law recommend Mario's to me) I have tried a few different items from their menu, and have never been disappointed! The food arrives on time and is always delicious!
Barry
4 reviews
Overall great experience. Food was on time, and tasted good. Only thing i would change is I would toss the salad with dressing and add croutons for the ceazer salad pizza. Other than that really well done.
Alison
2 reviews
Yummy food and fast delivery! The mixed vegetables with oil and garlic were more oily then expected but still tasted amazing (just may not be the thing to order if you're looking to stay super healthy)
Reviews from Seamless.com
Melanie
1 review
Food is always perfect and the delivery is always earlier than expected! Marios has great food and even better customer service. Very rare to find that in a pizzeria these days!
Michael
Top Reviewer
Food was delicious and on time. The best garlic knots I've ever had!!!
Dana
1 review
Hit the spot. Very pleased. Will order again.
Joseph
3 reviews
The Best Italian Food By Far!!!
Sara
Top Reviewer
Great food, will order again
About us
Calzones, Dinner, Italian, Lunch, Pasta, Pizza, Salads, Sandwiches, Wraps
Today
Delivery: 11:00 AM - 9:40 PM
Takeout: 11:00 AM - 9:40 PM
Since the opening of our first store in Oyster Bay over 35 years ago, Mario's Pizzeria has been serving quality food made with the finest ingredients and following 'Old World' traditional recipes. Currently, with eight locations across Long Island, Mario's Pizzeria expands its service to its customers. Mario's Pizzeria of Seaford is located on Long Island's South Shore just off Route 135 on Sunrise Highway and offers high quality food made with the finest ingredients, personalized service, unsurpassed value and the traditions of long ago in today's convenient world.come on in and join us for a memorable dining experience. We look forward to the opportunity to serve you.